Author Archives: F. E. Guerra-Pujol
In praise of Daniel Nina
Among the luminaries I met during my recent visit to Puerto Rico was my old colleague and friend Daniel Nina. (Thanks to the good efforts of Orlando Martinez-Garcia, we met at Professor Nina’s home office in Santurce on Thursday afternoon … Continue reading
Shout out to Orlando and Mireya
My wife Sydjia and I were going to spend this past weekend at the tropical Caribe Hilton in San Juan, Puerto Rico, but our close friends Orlando and Mireya invited us to stay with them at their home in the … Continue reading
Who spectates the impartial spectator?
When I endeavour to examine my own conduct, when I endeavour to pass sentence upon it, and either to approve or condemn it, it is evident that, in all such cases, I divide myself, as it were, into two persons; … Continue reading
Is the impartial spectator the Rube Goldberg of morality?
Nota bene: a Rube Goldberg machine is an elaborate chain-reaction-type contraption intentionally designed to perform a simple task in a comically overcomplicated way. I concluded my previous post by asking whether the man within the breast and the impartial spectator … Continue reading
Das Adam Smith impartial spectator problem redux
As I mentioned earlier this month, my colleagues Daniel Klein, Nicholas Swanson, and Jeffrey Young (KSY) have published a new paper in Econ Journal Watch, and their paper caught my attention because it’s about the impartial spectator in Adam Smith’s … Continue reading
Adam Smith’s *supposed impartial spectator*
One of Adam Smith’s most original ideas in The Theory of Moral Sentiments (TMS) is the “impartial spectator”, but who (or what) is this perplexing and puzzling observer? Thus far, we have seen how the Scottish philosopher refers to this … Continue reading
The impartial spectator as judge and tribunal
Correction (10/22): Based on the textual analysis of TMS in my 22 October blog post, I have to update my 21 October post below. To the point, I now see that Adam Smith is using the same set of metaphors … Continue reading
My interpretation of Adam Smith’s impartial spectator: part 1
One of Adam Smith’s most original — and mysterious — ideas in The Theory of Moral Sentiments (TMS) is the impartial spectator. But who or what is this enigmatic entity? My interpretation is based on the actual text of Smith’s … Continue reading

