*Resolving Feynman’s restaurant problem reveals optimal solutions and human strategies*

That is the title of this paper by Brian Christian, Evan M. Russek, and Thomas L. Griffiths, all of whom are affiliated with Princeton University. Here is their introduction:

“In the late 1970s, the physicist Richard Feynman sat down for lunch with his friend Ralph Leighton at a Thai restaurant called Indra in Glendale, California. Leighton was trying to decide whether to order his running favorite (the ginger chicken), or try something new that had a chance of being even better. Feynman turned the dilemma into a math problem—and solved it. Unfortunately Feynman never published his analysis. All that remained from the conversation were his handwritten notes, which Leighton happened to keep. The notes remained inscrutable for decades, until we managed to decipher them and reconstruct Feynman’s original problem and solution.”

More details here and here. Alas, I have to confess that when I first heard about the “Feynman restaurant problem” back in June of this year (see here), my first reaction was: “What’s the big deal? Feynman’s restaurant problem is just a ‘best-choice secretary problem’, a problem that was solved before the 1970s” (see here or here, for example). I am highlighting this problem now only because I just noticed a minor connection between Feynman’s restaurant problem and me: the restaurant that instigated Feynman’s investigation was located on Verdugo Blvd. in Glendale, California, just a few blocks from my childhood home!

Bonus link: My 2016 paper “Probabilistic Interpretation” models the problem of legal interpretation (i.e. how best to interpret a statute or constitutional provision) as a “best-choice secretary problem” in which a problem-solving judge strives to select the best interpretation of a given rule from a finite set of n possible interpretations of such rule. That paper, in turn, was was inspired by two of my heroes, Martin Gardner and Richard A. Posner.

Two pages of handwritten notes from Richard Feynman, defining and solving what is now known as Feynman's restaurant problem.
Image credit: Richard P. Feynman (estate)
Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Assorted SSRN links for Monday, 16 Nov 2026

The Social Science Research Network or “SSRN” is an open-access research platform used to share early-stage research and connect scholars around the world. Below is a small sample of some papers posted to SSRN that I have recently read or re-read:

  1. Gary Cornell, Swift’s “A Modest Proposal” is an Economics Working Paper: A Reassessment of Swift (1729)
  2. Jean-Baptiste Fleury and Alain Marciano, Richard A. Posner (1939–[2026])
  3. Stephen E. Henderson, In Defense of Pardons
  4. Steven L. Schwarcz and Isabelle Stewart, Towards a Unified Theory of Business Law
  5. Aaron Spikol, The Decision of 1802
  6. Cass R. Sunstein, Is There An Unthinkability Doctrine?
  7. Bonus link (blast-from-the-past/shameless self-promotion): F. E. Guerra-Pujol, Labor, Lockdowns, and Takings
CNR BEA | The Animal-Welfare Levy
Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Sunday song: Heartbreaker (multiple artists)

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

Adam Smith, Commissioner (Sep to Dec 1784): Conclusion

By way of background, I have been compiling (and am still in the process of transcribing) tens of dozens of legal orders signed by Adam Smith in his official capacity as a Commissioner of Customs in Scotland. The records in my collection thus far are from September 1784 until the beginning of 1787 — over 200 Smithian documents in all! — and I hope to expand this forgotten treasure trove to include all of the orders signed by Smith in his official commissioner role.

In the meantime, I began blogging about Smith’s tenure as a customs commissioner last month (see here), but because the task of tracking down and transcribing these orders has been so time-consuming and painstakingly arduous, I have decided to focus on the orders issued during the last four months of 1784 — i.e. from 16 September 1784 (Order #109, the day after the historic Commutation Act of 1784 took effect) until 30 December 1784 (Orders #144 & #145) — 19 orders in all. For further reference, I have compiled all of my recent posts surveying these orders one-by-one here:

  1. Adam Smith: bureaucrat? [Introduction]
  2. Adam Smith: accountant? [Order #109, 16 Sep]
  3. Adam Smith, bureaucrat (part 3) [Order #112, __ Oct]
  4. Adam Smith, bureaucrat (part 4) [Order #118, 1 Nov]
  5. Adam Smith, auditor [Order #119, 1 Nov]
  6. Adam Smith, anti-smuggler [Order #120, __ Nov]
  7. Adam Smith, Commissioner (part 7) [Order #121, __ Nov]
  8. Adam Smith, Commissioner (Part 8) [Order #123, 9 Nov]
  9. Adam Smith, Commissioner (Part 9) [Order #125, 15 Nov]
  10. Adam Smith, Commissioner (part 10) [Order #126, 15 Nov]
  11. Adam Smith, Commissioner (part 11) [Order #127, __ Nov]
  12. Adam Smith, Commissioner (part 12a) [Order #130, 15 Nov]
  13. Adam Smith, Commissioner (part 12b) [Order #132, __ Nov]
  14. Adam Smith, Commissioner (part 13) [Order #133, __ Dec]
  15. Adam Smith, Commissioner (part 14) [Order #135, 2 or 3 Dec]
  16. Adam Smith, Commissioner (part 15) [Order #137, 14 Dec]
  17. Adam Smith, Commissioner (part 16) [Order #141, 21 Dec]
  18. Adam Smith, Commissioner (part 17) [Order #143, __ Dec]
  19. Adam Smith, Commissioner (part 18) [Order #144, 30 Dec]
  20. Adam Smith, Commissioner (part 19) [Order #145, 30 Dec]

Besides the fact that each of these orders is addressed to the principal customs officers of the Port of Inverness (known as the Controller and Comptroller) and deals with some aspect of the operations of the customs service in Inverness, is there a deeper common thread or hidden theme running through all of these documents? That is a question I will leave to others (at least for now).

Adam Smith Biography | Insights into the Life of the Father of Economics |  Panmure House
Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Adam Smith, Commissioner (part 19)

The last document (for now [*]) in my initial sample of signed Adam Smith letters is Order #145, which like the previous order (#144) is also dated 30 December 1784 and signed by Basil Cochrane (top signature), Adam Smith (middle), and James Edgar (bottom). This order involves another more-or-less routine personnel matter:

“Having received your Letter of the 23d instant, inclosing the Memorial of Mr. Duncan Douglas [,] warranted to be a Landwaiter & Searcher at your Port, praying for the reasons therein set forth, that he may be instructed at Inverness. We acquaint you [with] the Information of Mr. Douglas that on the 16th instant, we directed the Collr. & Comptroller of Aberdeen to put him under the Care of the Landsurveyor and Landwaiter in order to [obtain] his Instruction and Qualification for the Office of a Landwaiter & Searcher at Inverness for which he is warranted and that this departure from the established Rule (Leith & Port Glasgow being the regular Instructing Ports) was owing to the ill health of Mr. Douglas and to the great inconvenience to which he would be put by being obliged to travel to those ports.”

Again, what in the Devil is going on here? In summary, an individual by the name of Duncan Douglas has received a formal Treasury warrant appointing him to the post of Landwaiter and Searcher [1] at the Port of Inverness in the Highlands of Scotland, but before taking up his new post Douglas has to undergo some on-the-job training (“instruction”) at one of Scotland’s major ports (“Leith & Port Glasgow”) and obtain a certificate of qualification. [2]

Ordinarily, a newly warranted officer like Douglas would be required to train in one of the designated “regular Instructing Ports” in Edinburgh (Leith) or the Clyde (Port Glasgow), two of the largest and busiest ports in Scotland. But owing to his ill health and the hardship of traveling all the way from Inverness to Leith or Port Glasgow, Douglas has submitted a “memorial” or request (forwarded by his superiors at Inverness to the Board of Customs on 23 Dec.) asking to be trained locally at Inverness.

As it happens, the board had already addressed this matter and had approved a compromise solution in a previous order dated December 16, allowing Douglas to complete his training at an outport closer to his home, i.e. Aberdeen instead of Inverness. Why did the commissioners refuse Douglas’s request to be trained at Inverness? Most likely because Inverness was too small an outport to provide comprehensive instruction or lacked the requisite supervisory personnel. Instead, the commissioners authorize a pragmatic compromise solution.

1939 MAP ~ SCOTLAND ~ SHIPPING ROUTES METAL INDUSTRIES COAL MINING PORTS  RAILWAY | eBay

[*] As I mentioned in my previous post, I have already compiled (and am in the process of transcribing) about 200 Smith letters in all (from September 1784 until the beginning of 1787 thus far), and I plan on expanding this burgeoning sample size to include all of Smith’s signed letters from 1784 (Jan. to Aug.) and the rest of 1787 as well as the years 1788 to 1790.

[1] Recall from a previous post (see here, for example) that Landwaiters and Searchers were frontline customs officers responsible for supervising the landing and shipping of goods, checking goods against the merchant’s entry warrants, and preventing smuggling or under-valuation. (See generally Elizabeth E. Hoon, The Organization of the English Customs System, 1696-1786 (reprint ed.), A. M. Kelley (1968), available here.)

[2] Because the duties of Landwaiters required technical proficiency in weighing and measuring cargo, bookkeeping, and calculating statutory tariffs and duties, new appointees like Douglas could not simply step into the role without formal training and certification. (See, e.g., Hoon, op. cit., pp. 204-207.)

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

Adam Smith, Commissioner (part 18)

Nota bene: Two days ago, the University of Chicago announced the death of Judge Richard A. Posner. One of the last of the great legal giants, no legal scholar did more to clarify our understanding of the law and expose the liberal bias and motivated reasoning of most legal academics than the polymath Judge Posner did. (Here is Judge Posner’s New York Times obituary.) I will have more to say about Dick Posner’s beautiful mind and his acerbic wit in the days ahead. Today, however, I want to begin wrapping up my multi-part series “Adam Smith, Commissioner.” I will therefore formally conclude my series this weekend with the last document in my sample of signed Adam Smith letters [*] and with some final observations on this last phase of Smith’s life before returning to Richard Posner in the next day or two.


The penultimate document in my sample of signed Adam Smith letters is Order #144, which is dated 30 December 1784 and is signed by Basil Cochrane (top signature), Adam Smith (middle), and James Edgar (bottom). To my mind, this order highlights the eternal tension between “law” and “equity”, between strict enforcement and equitable discretion:

“Having received your Report of the 23rd instant, on the Petition of Duncan Grant [,] Manufacturer in Forres, praying that the Duty may be remitted on a Cask of Flour Seed imported in the Friendship from Campvere in the Month of March last, which was omitted in the Report of the Master of the said Vessel; We upon considering the Circumstances of the Case, agree to the Duties on the said Flour Seed being exempted.”

What is going on here? In summary, a manufacturer based in the town of Forres in the northeast of Scotland (see maps pictured below) had imported a cask of “Flour Seed” from the port of Veere in the Netherlands. (Veere was known in Scotland as “Campvere” and was the staple port for Scotland between 1541 and 1799. [**]) The ship’s captain, however, had accidentally omitted this cask from the ship’s manifest when the cargo was being unloaded. As a result, the manufacturer petitions the principal officers at Inverness to waive whatever duties are owed on this cargo. The principal officers at Inverness write up a report and forward it, along with the manufacturer’s petition, to the Board of Customs in Edinburgh. After conducting their deliberations, the commissioners vote to waive the payment of duties.

Considering how strict we have seen the board to be thus far, this decision is somewhat surprising. Under British customs laws in force at the time (see, e.g., the Smuggling Act of 1781 (21 Geo. 3 c. 39)), any cargo omitted from a ship’s manifest was subject to seizure and forfeiture as uncustomed cargo. But at the same time, the central commissioners in London and Edinburgh have a certain level of equitable discretion when applying those same laws under extenuating circumstances. (Cf. Hoon 1968, p. 48 (footnote omitted): “Both the Lords of the Treasury and the Customs Commissioners could determine customs policy, though the final decision always lay with the Treasury Board. That body was possessed of vast powers in this connection for it could remit forfeitures and penalties under the customs laws ….”) Here, for instance, the commissioners decide to exercise their discretion, since the omission in this case appears to be an honest administrative error rather than intent to defraud the revenue.

File:Moray map.png
File:Moray in Scotland.svg

[*] Point of order: I have already compiled (and am in the process of transcribing) about 200 Smith letters in all (from September 1784 until the beginning of 1787 thus far), and I plan to expand this burgeoning sample size to include all of Smith’s signed letters from 1784 (Jan. to Aug.) and the rest of 1787 as well as the years 1788 to 1790.

[**] The origin port of Campvere (modern-day Veere in Zeeland, Netherlands) holds major economic significance. For centuries, Campvere served as the official “Scots Staple” port in the Low Countries, handling the bulk of Scotland’s imported flax, linseed, and industrial goods in exchange for exported wool and salmon. (See generally John Davidson and Alexander Gray, The Scottish Staple at Veere: A Study in the Economic History of Scotland, Longmans, Green & Co. (1909), available here.)

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

Adam Smith, Commissioner (part 17)

Next is Order #143, which is dated __ December 1784 (alas, the day is cut off) and is signed by Basil Cochrane (top signature), Adam Smith (middle), and James Edgar (bottom). This order deals with a local custom officer’s statutory reward or bounty for the confiscation of 30 kegs of smuggled beer:

“We have received your Letter of the 27th of November last, inclosing a Return of Seizure by Mr. Robert Anderson Land Surveyor for 30 Kegs Spruce Beer — and if it is to be understood from what is stated in the Return that the Cellar in which the Goods were seized was in the Possession of Baillie William Inglis, then the Officer is entitled to a Moiety, but if the meaning does not amount to this, then he will be entitled only to a Third; — as to which doubt We direct you to report precisely to Us.”

In brief, a customs officer, the land surveyor Robert Anderson, had confiscated 30 kegs of “Spruce Beer” [1]; as such, he is entitled to a share of the reward when the contraband is put up for sale at public auction. The problem, however, is that the size of Anderson’s share will depend on whether the confiscated kegs of beer were abandoned or unclaimed at the time when it was seized. [2]

Correspondence from the principal outport officers at Inverness (i.e. the letter the board is responding to in this case) includes Anderson’s “Return of Seizure” or official incident report, and according to his report, he had confiscated the contraband kegs in the cellar of one Baillie William Inglis. But there is an ambiguity in Anderson’s incident report. Who was Baillie William Inglis (the owner of the cellar), and what was his role in this case? Did the kegs belong to him, or were they hidden in his cellar by some third party, or did Anderson himself place the kegs there? (On this third possibility, recall one of the board’s previous orders, Order #132 from November 1784, in which Anderson was declared “incorrigible and unfit to be trusted any longer in the Revenue” and dismissed from the customs service.)

In short, was Ingliss a smuggler, an accomplice to a smuggler, or an innocent third party? The Commissioners of the Board of Customs thus want more information about circumstances surrounding this seizure before ratifying Anderson’s payout, especially given his prior bad acts. The board therefore orders Anderson’s supervisors (the Collector and Comptroller at Inverness to whom this order is addressed) to investigate this seizure further and report back their findings.

Cellar | George Washington's Mount Vernon

[1] According to Wikipedia, spruce beer “is a unique beverage flavored with the buds, needles, or essence of spruce trees.”

[2] See Customs Act 1763 (3 Geo. 3 c. 22), available here or here. Among other things, this statute established that the proceeds from public sales of condemned contraband were to be divided into “moieties” or halves—one moiety to the Crown; the other to the seizing officer. But the seizing officer’s statutory payout was reduced to one-third if the contraband was unclaimed or abandoned.

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

Adam Smith, Commissioner (part 16)

Back to our regularly scheduled programming (so to speak), the next document in my sample of signed Adam Smith letters is Order #141. This order is dated 21 December 1784 and is signed by David Reid (top signature), Adam Smith (middle), and James Edgar (bottom). Here, the commissioners of the Board of Customs respond to a letter from the principal outport officers at Inverness regarding ten bushels of contraband salt:

“We have received your Letter of the [*] Instant, acquainting Us that William Walker Master of the Sloop Rathia from Anstruther entered at your Port two thousand and four hundred Bushels [of] Scots Salt — That by the Landwaiter[‘]s Blue Book it appears ten Bushels were discharged more than entered and contained in the Cocket, and submitting whether it ought not to be returned as a Seizure — We direct you to prosecute the said [ten] Bushels of Salt to Condemnation before the Justices of the Peace, and when Condemned you are to sell the same by public Sale duly advertised to the best advantage taking care to Remit the King’s Share to the Receiver General and to transmit the Decree of Condemnation and Certificate of Sale to the Register of Seizures [,] acquainting us when you have so done.

In summary, the captain of a sloop arriving at Inverness from Anstruther (see map below) had declared an entry of 2,400 bushels of “Scots Salt”. Upon the unloading of this cargo, however, a customs officer (the Landwaiter) recorded in his official log (the “Blue Book”) that 10 extra bushels of salt were unloaded beyond what was declared in the vessel’s official shipping manifest (“the Cocket”). (Cf. Samuel Johnson’s Dictionary, which defines cocket as “a scroll of parchment, sealed and delivered by the officers of the customhouse to merchants, as a warrant that their merchandize is entered.”) What should happen to those extra ten bushels of salt?

The Board of Customs orders the principal outport officers at Inverness (the Controller and Comptroller) to proceed with the prosecution and condemnation of the excess bushels of salt before the local justices of the peace, sell the excess salt at a public auction, and remit the government’s share of the proceeds (“King’s Share“) to the Receiver General in Edinburgh. In addition, the board orders them to submit the local court’s condemnation order as well as the certificate of sale from the public auction to the central Register of Seizures. This meticulous order thus highlights three features of the 18th-century customs system in Scotland:

  • Zero-tolerance: This order underscores the no-nonsense, zero-tolerance approach of the central Board of Customs: a discrepancy of a mere 10 bushels of salt out of a total shipment of 2,400 bushels (or 0.04% of the total salt shipment) is treated as a serious infraction of the revenue laws. Every bushel must be accounted for!
  • Decentralized enforcement: The board directs the outport officers to prosecute the seizure before the local justices of the peace, a far more streamlined and faster legal mechanism for handling petty smuggling or minor manifest discrepancies in outports than the Court of Exchequer in Edinburgh or London.
  • Tons of paperwork: The outport officers had to inform the central Board of Customs of the discrepancy from the Landwaiter’s Blue Book, secure a formal decree of condemnation from a local court, advertise and conduct a public auction, split and remit some of the proceeds to the Receiver General, and then submit additional paperwork with the Register of Seizures.

Why so much paperwork–multiple letters, local court filings, public auction advertisements, and central treasury remittances–over just 10 bushels of salt? The main reason for this cumbersome system of reporting must have been the possibility of collusion between local revenue officers and unscrupulous ship captains or cost-cutting merchants. This was an era when frontline customs officers were poorly paid (see Hoon 1968, Ch. 6, especially pp. 211-220) and thus vulnerable to bribery or informal deals with local merchants or the smugglers themselves (see generally Muskett 1997), so perhaps all this paperwork was a form of accounting “check and balances”.

[*] The date is illegible.

MAP OF FIFE AND KINROSS BY H.MOLL 1732 — The Royal Mile Gallery

Bonus link: Scottish historian Richard Oram surveys Scotland’s medieval salt industry in the video lecture below.

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

*Coase’s fable* wins best paper award

My paper “Coase’s fable” has just won the “best paper award” this past weekend at this year’s meeting of the Southeast Academy of Legal Studies in Business (SEALSB) in beautiful Atlanta, Georgia! (I began writing this paper in 2025 and will post my revised work to SSRN in the next day or two; in the meantime, shout outs to my colleagues from previous academic conferences for their excellent contributions to my paper, including Humberto Barreto (Depauw) for pointing out Frank Knight’s influence on Ronald Coase, Steve Medema (Duke) for bringing to my attention the “LSE cost tradition”, and Mary Morgan (LSE) for suggesting the title of my paper.)

Update (10 Nov.): Here is a link to the paper.

Posted in Uncategorized | 4 Comments

Sunday song: Snooze (acoustic version)

I am in beautiful Atlanta attending the annual meeting of the Southeastern Academy of Legal Studies in Business (SEALSB), so I thought I would feature the artist SZA on my weekly Sunday song feature. Although SZA was born in St. Louis, Missouri, and raised in Maplewood, New Jersey, according to this website she has a direct and tangible connection to the ATL. Before pursuing music full-time, she moved to Georgia to study marine biology at Clark Atlanta University, and it was during her time in Atlanta that she officially adopted her stage name, “SZA,” and began recording the early collaborations that launched her to fame and fortune.

P.S.: Due to my travels, I will resume my “Adam Smith, Commissioner” series in the next day or two.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment