What is the most beautiful, haunting, and literary law review article of all time? In preparation for my upcoming talk on the life and legacy of Oliver Wendell Holmes (see my previous post), I want to say a few words about Holmes’s classic essay “The Path of the Law”, the first page of which is pictured below. To the point, my thesis is that Holmes’s work should be read as a short story or novella, for it is nothing less than a timeless masterpiece, along with the works of other great writers like Jorge Luis Borges and Ernest Hemingway.
As it happens, I explored Holmes’s seminal essay from a literary perspective in my article “Coase’s Parable“, which was published in a special symposium issue of the Mercer Law Review in May of 2023. (“The Problem of Social Cost” by Ronald H. Coase and Holmes’s “Path of the Law” are two of the most controversial, most cited, and most influential law review articles of all time.) Below the fold is an extended excerpt from my 2023 paper:
Continue reading











